Jamaica Plain, October 10, 2004, Rev. Terry Burke
Evelyn Underhill was one of the foremost writers on spiritual matters of the 20th century.
I'd read some of her books in Divinity School years ago, but thankfully, while preparing for the Mysticism in World Religions
class, my friend Toni Lester reminded me of her. In the relentless busyness of our day-to-day lives, Evelyn Underhill is a
good person to learn about, and to learn from her the importance of finding time for our spiritual lives.
Evelyn Underhill kept an embroidery in her bedroom with the one word "Eternity." She wrote especially about mysticism,
trying to grow closer to God through prayer. In her time, mysticism was associated at best with monks and nuns, people apart
from the world, and at worst with the occult and ouiji boards. Evelyn Underhill changed all that, and made mysticism an important
topic for all manner of persons.
Evelyn Underhill was born in 1875 to a British Upper Middle Class family. Her father was a lawyer.
Her family were Anglicans who might go to church on Christmas or Easter. She later wrote, "I was not brought up to religion."
Evelyn attended and graduated from the University of London, where she studied botany, philosophy, languages, and
social sciences. By the time of her college years, she had become a philosophical theist, believing in God, socialism,
and helping the poor.
After college, a trip to
Italy made her comfortable entering Catholic churches to look at the art work or light candles.
Evelyn and a friend went on a retreat at a British Catholic convent; afterwards, she had a profound religious experience,
something of the intensity of Isaiah's visionary call. Evelyn had an overwhelming experience of the truth of faith,
which she placed in a Catholic context. In much the same way, a generation later, the
German academic Edith Stein could read St. Teresa's autobiography on a weekend holiday and become convinced
that it was "the truth."
Evelyn's fiancée Hubert, a friend since childhood, was horrified by her decision to enter the Roman Catholic Church.
This was during the era when J.R.R. Tolkien's mother was cut off by her parents for converting to Catholicism.
Hubert was a lawyer who liked to "mess about in boats." He was very "handy;" during WWI
he invented a new type of splint that was named for him. Hubert especially detested the idea of confession in the Catholic Church.
A wise priest suggested that Evelyn tell Hubert that she would wait a year before converting. In the intervening year,
the Pope issued an encyclical against all forms of "Modernism" or liberalism in the Catholic Church. Evelyn Underhill could
only have been a liberal modernist Catholic, so she lost her spiritual home. She felt "stuck" spiritually.
Evelyn married Hubert and turned to writing. The Grey World, a novel of hers about the spiritual search, was very popular.
She wrote poems and other novels. In 1911 she published a great scholarly work entitled Mysticism. The Boston Public Library has
four copies of the work at their Copley main branch and it has never been out of print. In the book Underhill describes the stages
of mysticism in the traditions of the world religions. She had a strong belief that all mystics were ultimately at one with each
other. She also presented the mystic as doer, not dreamer; a closer relationship with the Divine brought a more abundant life of
greater creativity and service to others.
Much the same way as Scot Peck's books like The Road Less Traveled reached spiritual people outside of the church in the
1980's, Underhill's books revealed a deep spiritual need. She had found her vocation - writing on prayer. Her many books and
articles on prayer often tried to reach people who were not conventionally religious. For example, one of my favorite books of
Underhill's is entitled, Practical Mysticism, a Little Book for Real People. She collaborated with the Indian poet Tagore on
translations of the mystic Kabir, another figure who didn't fit well with the religions of his time.
As a result of her book on mysticism, Underhill acquired a "family" of persons for whom she was spiritual director, helping them
grow in their relationship with God. A woman serving as a spiritual director had been unheard of. Underhill realized her own need
for spiritual direction, and turned to the great German writer on mysticism, Baron von Hugel. Reading von Hugel convinced my
teacher, Unitarian Universalist ethicist James Luther Adams, to be in spiritual direction in Paris in the 1930's. Adams then
convinced me to start spiritual direction in the 1970's.
Von Hugel wrote Underhill that her faith was too intellectual, and that she should spend more time with the poor for her own good.
Underhill found her way back to the Anglican Church, but as a very ecumenical Christian, who delighted in conferences and
dialogue with Catholics and Eastern Orthodox. She was part of a society of women from many backgrounds who prayed on their own
for the unity of the Church. Then Evelyn Underhill started leading spiritual retreats at a religious community in Pleshy, another
first for a woman of her time.
Underhill was considered the greatest retreat leader of her time. A slight, smallish person, she has been described as
having a wonderful smile, intense eyes, and a good sense of humor, especially when speaking on the most serious of subjects.
She led retreats for lay people, Anglican priests, and other clergy. She especially warned the clergy to find time for prayer in
the midst of their busy lives - that was in the 1920's and 30's! I think Evelyn Underhill would have approved of the Mass. Council
of Churches' current program to Take Back Your Time, to take some time out of our working busyness for family, friends and
spiritual life.
Evelyn Underhill was also the first woman to give various important titled lectures at Oxford and Cambridge.
The University of Aberdeen gave her an honorary Doctor of Divinity degree; she made clear that she was never to be called Dr.
Underhill and remembered how the Lord Rector of Aberdeen had pulled her hair as a child. She didn't like being made into a sort of
cardboard saint; after reading a highly reverential review of a new book of hers, she cut her hair extremely short in response.
Writing, leading retreats, and giving spiritual direction was lonely, hard work. She was assailed by doubts about her faith
and work. Usually, she was the only woman in her fields of activity. She developed severe asthma. Underhill took a year off
from retreats and wrote a monumental study of worship. A pamphlet of Aldous Huxley's convinced her of the importance of pacifism,
and she remained true to her Christian pacifism even during World War II. In a meditation written for the Fellowship for
Reconciliation, she compared pacifists to 'redeemers who must be crucified for peace.'
Her health failing, Underhill agreed to take over her local church school confirmation class of 11-14 year olds when the
priest fell seriously ill - something like having St. Teresa in your Sunday School! She was delighted when she asked the class,
"Why do we praise God?" and one child answered, "To cheer Him up!" She died calmly at the age of 65, having written shortly
before, 'trusting God means…through thick and thin."
Evelyn Underhill the mystic was also a gardener who loved flowers. She loved the light in Norway on trips with her husband.
She was a devoted friend, and a wonderful host who enjoyed having peope over for dinner. She was a bookbinder whose work was
bought by museums. She was especially a lover of cats; when something was really good she described it as "purry," and her cats
wrote letters to the local papers. She cherished a cat crèche nativity set with all the animals cats made by some of her
spiritual directees.
Evelyn Underhill is a good example of the creativity and more abundant life of service of someone far along mystical path of
the love of God. She was not an academic or a theologian or a clergy person, but rather shows the beauty and power of an
ordinary person in the light of God. In our busy, busy, busy lives, Evelyn Underhill reminds us to take time for the silence of
God and eternity in our lives.
Reading from Mysticsm, by Evelyn Underhill
Like the story of the Cross, so too the story of the human spirit ends in a garden: in a place of birth and fruitfulness,
of beautiful and natural things. Divine Fecundity is its secret: existence, not for its own sake but for the sake of a more
abundant life. It ends with the coming forth of divine humanity, never again to leave us: living in us, and with us, a pilgrim,
a worker, a guest at our table, a sharer at all hazards in life. The mystics witness to this story: waking very early they have
run on before us, urged by the greatness of their love. We, incapable as yet of this sublime encounter, looking in their magic
mirror, listening to their stammered tidings, may see far off the consummation of the human race.